Where to eat in New Buffalo Michigan?
Restaurants, Bars, Grills and Eateries

There are COVID-19 Restrictions in place for restaurants and bars – Outdoor dining and take-out only. Call ahead to see if an establishment is open for business during the State-mandated safety precautions (currently set @ Nov 18 – Dec 9, 2020).

It took us a while to venture over from Four Winds to try Heston’s. Best snap decision imaginable. Aside from the appearance which is classic for a midwestern supper club, trom the start the courtesy and friendliness of the staff from front of house to bar to table was first rate. Bar staff makes a proper martini. Visiting Lake Michigan? Stay at Four Winds Casino New Buffalo located less than an hour away from Chicago and featuring gaming, dining and entertainment.

Besides the household names commonly associated with a quick meal like Subway and McDonald’s, New Buffalo, Michigan has some unique independent restaurants that will appeal just about everybody.

• Bentwood Tavern
  Marina Grand Resort
  600 W. Water St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Beer Church Brewing Co.
  24 S Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117-1820
  (219) 771-0635

• Brewsters Italian Cafe
  Wood-fired Pizza, Pasta, Salads, & Deli
  11 W. Merchant Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3005

• Casey’s Bar & Grill
  American Cuisine – late night dining
  136 N. Whittaker Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-6400

• Copper Rock Steakhouse
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11113 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• David’s Delicatessen
  30 N. Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-7177

• Dinner’s Ready…Set…Go!
  424 E. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1702

• Dooley’s Lake House Pub
  310 West Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-2247

• El Rancho Grande
  310 E. Buffalo Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9600

• Four Winds Casino Buffet
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (866) 494-6371

• Fresco
  108 North Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 612-4000

• Ghost Isle Brewery
  17684 U.S. 12
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9069

• I CAN Café
  910 W Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9957

• Jackie’s Cafe
  801 W. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1800

• Kankakee Grille
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  1-866-494-6371

• Luisa’s Cafe
  13698 Red Arrow Hwy
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9037

• McDonalds
  18881 La Porte Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1924

• Nancy’s
  Walk-up treats & Hot Dogs
  142 N Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-4240

• New Buffalo Beach Club
  Milkshakes, Fries, Sandwiches, Wraps and more
  @ the Public Beach
  New Buffalo, MI 49117

• Oinks Dutch Treat
  Ice cream & atmosphere!
  227 W Buffalo St (across from City Hall)
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3535

• Pizza Hut/Wings Street
  700 E. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-6900

• Redamak’s
  Popular Seasonal Hangout – Burgers
  616 East Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-4522

• Roma Pizza
  17600 Red Arrow Hwy
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3698

• Rios Mexican Food
  901 W Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-8011

• Rosie’s Restaurant
  American cuisine
  128 North Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-4382

• Sage Bistro
  9 South Barton St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9542

• Skip’s Restaurant & Catering
  Prime Rib & steaks
  16710 Lakeshore Road
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  Shuttle Bus Available
  (269) 469-3330

• Song Asian Cuisine
  301 W. Buffalo St (US-12)
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 586-3699

• Stray Dog Bar & Grill
  Breakfast/Brunch, Late Night
  245 North Whittaker Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-2727

• Terrace Cafe & Lounge
  at the Harbor Grand
  111 West Water Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Timbers Fast Food & Deli
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (866) 494-6371

• Villa Nova Pizzeria
  134 W. Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-0200

• White Birch Market
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11113 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
• Whittaker Woods
  12578 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3400
• Zoe’s Gourmet
  910 W Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 586-0200

To Make NEW YEAR’S EVE Reservations Using Our Online Reservation Form, Click HERE

**A member of our team will contact you via email within 48 hours with a confirmation

At this time we are FULL at our 4:00 and 6:00 seating blocks

Heston Supper Club has reopened following guidelines set forth by the State of Indiana. Click here to view our dinner menu for both dine in and carry out.

Due to these guidelines set by Governor Holcomb, tables will be limited to only six (6) guests maximum and we will be seating at a limited capacity in our dining rooms. Furthermore, at this time, we are only allowed to have 50% capacity in our lounge and bar.

Guidelines, along with our COVID-19 Safety Plan, can be found on our website by clicking the links above.

Dress Code
Casual Fine Dining No Dress Code Face Coverings Required When Moving Around In The Restaurant

Credit Cards
Visa MasterCard American Express

Handicapped Access
Ramped Entrance One Level Dining Restroom

Cuisine
Specializing in Prime Rib Of Beef. We also offer a wide array of Hand Cut Steaks, Chops, Seafood and House Smoked Barbeque

Hours (CT)

Mon-Sat: 4 pm - Close
Sun: 3 pm - Close

*At this time, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, our lounge will not open prior to the dining rooms.

Four Winds Casino New Buffalo Michigan Phone Number

Restaurants At Four Winds Casino New Buffalo Michigan Restaurants

Restaurants At Four Winds Casino New Buffalo Michigan Bed And Breakfast